One of the original structures owned by the Devery family, the church was consecrated around the same time as Lordville Presbyterian in 1896. The land that the church stood on was donated by Samuel McKinney- son of Irish immigrant, Mahlon McKinney. The church was deconsecrated in 1954 due to declining membership and slowly rotted away. Only the back wall and foundation remain. Today the grounds of the church belong to Callie and Greg Brunelli.